Walmart and Iowa Food Prices

Walmart and Iowa Food Prices


by Paul Deaton

[Editor's
Note: This is the fourth article in a Blog for Iowa series about food
and food pricing in Iowa, centered around a comparison shopping trip to
buy ingredients for a bowl of vegetarian chili. Read the previous articles
by clicking here, here or here].

Walmart had significantly lower prices on five ingredients on our shopping list for a vegetarian chili recipe. A lime, two 15 ounce cans of kidney beans, a pound of onion, a can of tomato paste and 12 ounces of veggie burger crumbles cost $7.08 at Walmart. This was $2.28 or 24.4% below the next lowest price at Hy Vee. It is hard to ignore substantially lower prices when many Iowans are pinching pennies. At the same time, grocery shopping is not always about price, as mentioned in our second article.

There is also a symbiotic relationship between social concerns about Walmart and its low prices.  It is difficult to ignore the economic and social impact of Walmart stores in a community. (To get one perspective, view the video Walmart: The High Cost of Low Price here). While some weigh in against shopping at Walmart under any circumstances, a majority of Iowans find their way into a Walmart Supercenter at least once during the year. For purposes of Blog for Iowa’s food pricing discussion, and because the topic of Walmart food pricing is so broad, I will narrow my focus to two aspects of how Walmart delivers low prices: vendor relationships in this article, and overhead (specifically labor practices) in the next.

A friend of mine, a small business owner and entrepreneur, recently wrote about the prospect of being a Walmart vendor,

“What about the opportunity for small entrepreneurs to introduce their products at Walmart and become instantly wealthy?  Don't hold your breath.  The vendor vetting process is so exhausting and demanding, fraught with demands for cutting margin and reduced profits for the manufacturers that most American small businesses can't afford to sell through Walmart… even if they could get an appointment with the purchasing department.”

In a past life, the author worked with large manufacturers who sell to Walmart. Their vendor experience is similar to my friend’s description. It is demanding and it does reduce margins. Walmart’s relationship with vendors is about consistent scale, manufacturing capacity and measurable performance. To participate, a manufacturer must offer prices lower than competitors and assured compliance with well defined and contractually agreed Walmart criteria.

In an agreement with Walmart, a vendor can increase manufacturing productivity and gain buying power with its vendors. Doing business with a well capitalized company like Walmart produces a satisfactory, if lower, gross margin and can help with financial planning and accounts receivable. All of these things serve to reduce costs for a large or mid-sized operation, enabling low prices. For a mid-sized manufacturer, a board of directors’ discussion may well be how big a bite of the Walmart apple to take in an annual business plan. For a small scale operation, the maze of rules may seem too big a hassle.

My point is this. Because of the scale and a well defined purchasing process, Walmart drives vendors to be more efficient and thereby lower costs. An example from our shopping survey is the veggie burger crumbles. In four of five instances, these were manufactured by Kellogg’s subsidiary Morningstar Farms. Walmart’s price was $3.32 compared to Hy Vee and Sam’s Main Street Market at $4.59 and John’s Grocery at $5.19. It is the purchasing process and contractual relationships with large manufacturers like Kellogg's that drive Walmart’s low prices.

There is nothing unethical about this, as a signed contract presumes agreement by the parties entering into it. Walmart is very good at purchasing and this skill contributes significantly to their lowest prices in our shopping survey. If a person supports American business at all, it is difficult to argue with Walmart's successful purchasing program.

~Paul
Deaton is a native Iowan living in rural Johnson County and weekend
editor of Blog for Iowa.
E-mail Paul
Deaton

This entry was posted in Corporate Greed, Main Page, Organic Foods & Farming, Progressive Community. Bookmark the permalink.